data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/624a3/624a35e700b2f4fa0796b49b59b3b203938d8547" alt=""
Most capital cities have a train station in the middle of town — that was almost the case for Canberra.
This week's question comes from Beck Pearse, an academic who lived in Canberra's north.
Beck travelled regularly between Canberra and Sydney by bus.
"Given that the train is four-and-a-half hours and only runs two times a day, adding the trip over to Kingston just makes it an untenable journey for me," she said.
It made her wonder why Canberra's train station wasn't more centrally located.
And like many Curious Canberrans who get in touch, Beck had done some of her own research.
Many of you have asked about the rumoured Civic station, and after you voted for Beck's question in June we managed to find proof of its existence.
An accidental station
The train station in Kingston was never meant to be Canberra's main, or only, station.
"It was to bring goods, particularly building materials, in for the early construction of the city and to bring coal to the [Kingston] Powerhouse."
The railway line was completed in 1914, and connected the newly-named capital to the existing railway line across the border, in Queanbeyan.
The station's proximity to the powerhouse explains its location but not how it came to be Canberra's only station. That's a slightly longer story, which starts with a disagreement.
Mark Butz knows the story well, he runs rail tours for the ACT Railway Historical Society and Engineering Heritage Australia.
"The people who originally thought about locating the city, which were surveyors mostly and some engineers, thought that would be the logical place to put the city — on the southside," he said
"That meant the [Kingston] railway station was in the perfect place to serve as the centre of the city."
Amy Lay, an exhibitions curator at the National Archives of Australia, had come across this too.
"This is a problem because there's different ideas about how the city should look."
She believes that this could have had an impact on how Canberra's railway was funded.
Records show that Griffin's proposed railway line — a permanent line that would travel through the city and connect to Sydney and Melbourne via Yass — was costed multiple times, by the engineer-in-chief and even by Griffin himself.
Bureaucrats then suggested alternative rail lines, some of which didn't go as far as Civic or travelled through the south, deviating from Griffin's plans.
"The plan was, by 1915, not to bother with these permanent lines, temporary ones were decided upon."
What was built in 1920 was a temporary line that went from Kingston station, across the Molonglo River and onto Civic, terminating in Braddon.
Like the early Kingston line, it was designed to aid construction, this time in the city's north.
"Unfortunately, it [the train] crossed the Molonglo River on a fairly flimsy timber bridge," said David.
"About 18 months after it was constructed, a flood came down the Molonglo and wiped the bridge out."
Its destruction marked a turning point in Canberra's rail history.
A decade after the Kingston station was built, it became a "bona fide passenger line".
A longer platform was built in 1924 to accommodate passengers, and by 1927, a new station building was ready to welcome parliamentarians who were relocating from Melbourne to Canberra.
What could've been — Civic station
Many Canberrans have asked whether there was ever a train station in Civic, where Garema Place is today.
The answer is yes, and no.
"It certainly wasn't a railway station," said Mark Butz.
If it still stood, Mark believes it would be in the middle of Garema Place, roughly where the concrete chess board is today.
The line didn't match Griffin's plans exactly because its primary function was to transport workers and building materials.
It picked up workers from a platform in Russell and brought them into Civic.
"This one here in Garema Place, that was very much a temporary thing," Mark said.
But Civic station wouldn't have been the city's central station.
"The actual railway itself was intended to go much closer to Mount Ainslie … with a big station under his big market building, which is pretty much where the Australian-American memorial is now."
High-speed rail?
On hearing the story of Canberra's railway lines, Beck couldn't help but laugh.
Still, she wanted to know whether rail was still being discussed today, especially high-speed rail.
Earlier this year, the ACT Chief Minister called for a train service between Sydney and Canberra that would take less than three hours.
Even if a new rail project gets the go-ahead for the capital, a station in the CBD isn't guaranteed.
"The way the city's evolved now, I can't see anyway that there could ever be a full railway station in the city," Mark Butz said.
"If there was a rail link to the north, it would be much closer to the airport … where we've got the parkway and that transport infrastructure."